Average email popup conversion rate for Shopify stores, 2026: what's a good opt-in rate (with real data)
Ask three popup vendors what the average popup conversion rate is and you get three numbers, and they are not close. Sleeknote says 4.23%. Wisepops says 4.5%. OptiMonk says 11.09%. All three published their figures in 2026, all three measured hundreds of millions of impressions, and all three are telling the truth about their own data. The gap is in what they count, and once you untangle that, a Shopify store gets a usable answer: a plain email popup converts around 3 to 5% of the people who see it, a discount-for-email popup around 5 to 8%, and a gamified one 8 to 13%.
Here is the short version, with sources:
- Average popup conversion rate: 4.23%, across 516,866,935 popup views and 21,875,675 leads on Sleeknote’s platform, up from 4.13% a year earlier.(source)
- Popup engagement rate: 4.5%, across 22.6 million popup impressions on 2,461 sites using Wisepops in the first half of 2026, which captured 210,634 emails and earned an attributed $128 per 1,000 impressions.(source)
- Klaviyo’s benchmark for a sign-up form submit rate: 3%. one of Klaviyo’s senior digital strategists calls that a low bar and has worked with brands at 8 to 20%.(source)
- OptiMonk’s all-popup average: 11.09%, but its incentive-free newsletter popups convert at 5.10%, ebook offers at 7.49%, discount-for-email at 7.65% and lucky wheels at 13.23%. The 11.09% is lifted by cart-recovery popups (17.12%) and seasonal offers (11.88%) that only ask for a click.(source)
- 69% of Shopify stores run a popup, 61% trade a discount code for an email, and only 41% show popups on mobile, the device where both datasets say popups convert better (Wisepops, 500 Shopify stores, March to June 2026).(source)
The rest of this post goes through each of those with the receipts attached, then gets to what a Shopify store should do with its number.
What “popup conversion rate” actually measures (and why the vendors disagree)
The formula is the same everywhere: conversions divided by the number of times the popup was shown. The disagreements live in both halves of that fraction.
What counts as a conversion. For an email popup it is a submitted form. For a cart-recovery or seasonal-offer popup it is a click on the button. OptiMonk’s 11.09% average pools both kinds; its cart abandonment popups (shown to people who already have items in the cart) convert at 17.12% because the “conversion” is a click, not a typed email address.(source) Sleeknote’s 4.23% is leads divided by views, so it is an email-capture rate.(source) Wisepops defines two separate metrics and is careful about which is which: an engagement rate (engagements divided by call-to-action impressions, 4.5% for popups) and a capture rate (emails divided by impressions).(source) Klaviyo’s submit rate is submitted form events divided by viewed form events, and its help documentation notes that it counts every visitor’s submission, not just unique profiles, and that an update removing non-human interactions from the view count pushed submit rates up.(source)
What counts as a view. A popup “view” is one display, and a visitor can be shown the same popup on several pages or several visits. None of these rates is “share of unique visitors who gave you an email”, and your own number will look different depending on whether you cap impressions to once per session.
Whose popups are in the sample. Each dataset is the customers of one vendor. Sleeknote’s and Wisepops’ customer bases skew toward ecommerce brands that pay for a popup tool and presumably care about the result; OptiMonk’s 2026 page describes its sample as “countless popups created by OptiMonk users” without a count.(source) Treat all of them as benchmarks of stores that are trying, not of every store on Shopify.
The practical consequence: compare your email popup to the email-popup numbers (Sleeknote’s 4.23%, OptiMonk’s 5.10% to 7.65%, Klaviyo’s 3%), not to the all-popup 11.09%.
The headline numbers, side by side
| Source | Figure | What it measures | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sleeknote, 2026 | 4.23% average popup conversion rate (4.13% a year earlier) | Leads ÷ popup views | 516,866,935 views, 21,875,675 leads, Sleeknote platform(source) |
| Wisepops, H1 2026 | 4.5% popup engagement rate | Engagements ÷ call-to-action impressions | 22.6M popup impressions, 2,461 sites, 210,634 emails captured(source) |
| Klaviyo | 3% benchmark sign-up form submit rate | Submitted ÷ viewed form events | Klaviyo’s stated general benchmark; one of its senior strategists reports brands at 8 to 20%(source) |
| OptiMonk, 2026 | 11.09% all popups · 5.10% plain newsletter · 7.65% discount for email | Conversions ÷ views, all popup types pooled | OptiMonk users, sample size not stated(source) |
| OptiMonk, top 10% of popups | 42.35% | Same | Same(source) |
Two things to notice. The three email-shaped figures (4.23%, 4.5%, 3%) land within a couple of points of each other despite coming from three unrelated platforms, which is about as much corroboration as this corner of ecommerce data ever gets. And OptiMonk’s own email figures (5.10% and 7.65%) sit in the same neighbourhood once you strip out the click-only campaigns. The 11.09% is not wrong; it is answering a different question.
Conversion rate by popup type and incentive
This is the table most merchants actually need, because “a popup” is not one thing. Two datasets break it down by what the popup asks for and offers.
| Popup type | OptiMonk, 2026 | Sleeknote, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Newsletter signup, no incentive | 5.10%(source) | not broken out |
| Newsletter signup, ebook or content offer | 7.49%(source) | not broken out |
| Newsletter signup, discount offer | 7.65%(source) | not broken out |
| Spin-to-win / lucky wheel | 13.23%(source) | 8.67% (vs 3.70% without gamification)(source) |
| Quiz popup | 15.2%(source) | 8.65%(source) |
| Daily offer (new deal each day, unlocked by signing up) | not broken out | 29.59%, highest in the study(source) |
| Feedback / survey popup | 12.62%(source) | not broken out |
| Seasonal offer | 11.88%(source) | not broken out |
| Cart abandonment (exit intent with items in cart) | 17.12%, click conversion(source) | not broken out |
The absolute numbers differ between the two platforms (OptiMonk’s run higher across the board) but the ordering agrees: asking for an email with nothing in return is the hardest ask, a discount helps, and turning the ask into a game or a quiz roughly doubles the rate. OptiMonk’s explanation for why email popups underperform its other campaigns is the simplest one: typing an address takes more effort than clicking a button, and the visitors who see an email popup are mostly new, at the start of their journey.(source)
One row worth a second look for Shopify stores: feedback popups at 12.62%. Asking a visitor a question converts better than asking for their email. That is the logic behind running an on-storefront survey on a product page or a collection, where the answer tells you why people are not buying and costs the visitor nothing.
Mobile vs desktop: the number most Shopify stores get backwards
| Device | Sleeknote, 2026 | OptiMonk, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Mobile | 5.60%(source) | 11.07%(source) |
| Desktop | 2.86%(source) | 9.69%(source) |
Both datasets have mobile ahead; Sleeknote’s gap is 97%.(source) Now set that against what Shopify stores actually do: Wisepops’ 2026 audit of 500 stores found 69% run a popup but only 41% show one on mobile, so a large slice of stores run their popup on the device where it converts worse and switch it off on the device where it converts better.(source) That is up sharply from 15% showing mobile popups in 2023, so the gap is closing, but it is still the single most common way a Shopify store leaves email on the table.
The usual reason for desktop-only is Google’s rule against intrusive mobile interstitials. Sleeknote’s answer, which we would echo, is that a teaser (the small tab a visitor taps to open the offer) counts as a user-initiated action, and its data has popups with a teaser converting at 4.54% against 2.74% without one.(source) Littledata’s October 2026 benchmark across 438 Shopify stores puts the median mobile traffic share at 66%, so a desktop-only popup is skipped by two visitors in three before it has a chance to convert anyone.(source)
What Shopify stores actually run (500-store audit, 2026)
Wisepops visited 500 English-language Shopify stores doing $100,000 to $250,000 a month, between 1 March and 10 June 2026, on desktop and mobile, with a return visit the next day with an item left in the cart. The findings are a map of what “normal” looks like on a mid-sized Shopify store.(source)
| Measure (share of 500 Shopify stores) | 2026 | 2023 |
|---|---|---|
| Run at least one popup | 69% | 62% (50% in 2018) |
| Run a discount-code-for-email popup | 61% | n/a |
| Show a popup on mobile | 41% | 15% |
| Run a multi-step popup (email first, then phone or a question) | 48% | 17% |
| Run more than one popup campaign | 38% | 29% |
| Collect phone numbers | 39% | n/a |
| Have a separate campaign for returning visitors | 8% | 1% |
| Offer a first-order discount (any channel) | 74% | n/a |
| Klaviyo as the email app | 68% | n/a |
Source: Wisepops, The State of Visitor Engagement on Shopify Stores, 2026 edition.(source)
Among the 74% of stores offering a first-order discount, 10% off is the most common (32% of them), then 20% off (18%) and 15% off (14%), and the mix has shifted toward the smaller figure since 2023.(source) So if your welcome popup says 10% off, you are running the modal Shopify popup, which is fine, and also the one every visitor has seen before.
The 8% figure is the one to sit with. Every store in the sample had an offer for first-time visitors; almost none showed a returning visitor anything different, even when that visitor came back with an item still in the cart.(source) Given that a returning visitor has already declined your welcome popup once, showing it again is the clearest way to train people to close popups on reflex.
The design levers, ranked by how much the data agrees
Both 2026 studies tested the same handful of variables. Where they agree, treat the lever as real. Where they disagree, treat it as a test to run on your own store.
Agree: gamification roughly doubles the rate. Sleeknote: spin-to-win 8.67% vs 3.70% without gamification, a 132% lift.(source) OptiMonk: lucky wheels 13.23% against 5.10% to 7.65% for standard email popups.(source) The catch both vendors name: a wheel has to give away something, so the margin cost of the list goes up with the opt-in rate.
Agree: a countdown timer helps, when the deadline is real. Sleeknote: 5.17% with a timer vs 4.12% without, a 25% lift. OptiMonk: 14.41% vs 9.86%.(source)(source)
Agree: fewer fields. Sleeknote: 4.41% with one input, 2.90% with two, 1.93% with three; and 76% of people who complete step one of a multi-step popup complete step two, which is why 48% of Shopify stores now split the ask.(source)(source)
Agree: timing matters, and “immediately” is wrong. Sleeknote’s timer-led triggers (about six seconds in) convert at 4.42% against 2.64% for scroll-based triggers.(source)
Disagree: images. This is the biggest contradiction in the 2026 data. Sleeknote reports popups with an image converting at 4.05% against 0.66% without, a 513% lift and the largest swing in its study.(source) OptiMonk reports 11.09% with images and 11.08% without, no difference at all.(source) We do not know which is right for your store, and neither do they. Test it.
Format, with a caveat. Sleeknote has centered popups at 4.68%, slide-ins at 3.69% and sticky bars at 2.85%, and argues each format has a different job (the bar stays visible all session, so it suits an always-on free-shipping message).(source) OptiMonk reports fullscreen popups at 14.40%, with the warning that fullscreen without good targeting annoys people.(source) Higher conversion from a more intrusive format is not free; the cost shows up in the sessions you did not convert, which is where the last section of this post comes in.
The discount question, in revenue terms
Opt-in rate is the vanity half of the metric. The half that pays is what a subscriber goes on to spend, and the best public data on that is Klaviyo’s, from its data science team’s analysis of sign-up forms with and without a discount:(source)
- Forms with a discount had 90% higher subscription rates than forms without an offer.
- Visitors who saw a discount form were 190% more likely to make a first purchase than those who saw a non-discount form.
- Discount forms produced almost 200% more revenue per view and 60% higher average revenue per sign-up.
So the discount does not just inflate the list; by Klaviyo’s data it produces more revenue per impression and more revenue per subscriber. The counter-argument (you are discounting people who would have paid full price) is real, and Klaviyo’s post acknowledges the profitability question, but the published numbers come down on the side of offering something.
For the per-impression economics, Wisepops’ H1 2026 report puts attributed revenue from popups at $128 per 1,000 impressions, against $779 per 1,000 for its onsite feed, with the note that the popup reaches far more people (76.6% of all onsite impressions and 83.0% of attributed revenue in its sample) and the feed’s higher rate comes from visitors who chose to open it.(source) Attribution is the vendor’s own, so read the absolute dollars as directional; the shape (popups win on reach, not on revenue per view) is the useful part.
Seasonality: November is a different metric
Sleeknote’s ecommerce data has the average popup conversion rate jumping to 9.3% in November, 125% above the yearly average, and in a separate analysis of 84 million ecommerce sessions, brands collected 52.5% more subscribers in November than in an average month, with 67% of those sessions on mobile.(source) If you benchmark your popup against the 4.23% average using November data, you will think you are a genius; benchmark January against it and you will think the popup is broken. Compare like months. (The wider November picture is in our Shopify BFCM statistics.)
Limits of popup benchmarks, read before you panic
Every dataset here is one vendor’s customers. Sleeknote, Wisepops, OptiMonk and Klaviyo each measured the stores using their own tool. None is a sample of Shopify stores at large, and a store that pays for a popup platform is already more invested in the result than one using a theme’s built-in newsletter block.
The definitions differ, so the numbers do too. Leads over views (Sleeknote), engagements over call-to-action impressions (Wisepops), submits over form views with bots removed (Klaviyo), all popup types pooled (OptiMonk). A 4% and an 11% can describe the same popup.
Views are not visitors. Impression capping, frequency rules and multi-page sessions all change the denominator. Your rate measured per unique visitor will be higher than your rate measured per display.
The Shopify adoption study is mid-sized stores. Wisepops’ 500-store sample was $100,000 to $250,000 a month in revenue, English-language, in six verticals, and the authors say so.(source) A new store should expect lower adoption numbers around it and no particular reason to match them.
A higher opt-in rate is not automatically a better business. A wheel that converts 13% of visitors with a 20% discount can lose money against a plain form converting 5% with no discount. Judge the popup on revenue per impression and the list on what it goes on to buy, which is why the Klaviyo revenue figures above matter more than any rate in this post.
How to know if your popup is actually fine
A quick self-assessment, calibrated to the data above:
- Plain email popup, no incentive, converting 3 to 5%: normal. That is where Klaviyo’s benchmark, Sleeknote’s average and OptiMonk’s newsletter figure all sit. The cheap upgrade is a discount or a quiz, not a redesign.
- Discount-for-email popup converting under 5%: below the OptiMonk discount figure of 7.65% and the general average. Check the three mechanical levers first: fields (one, then a second step), trigger (a few seconds in, not on load), and whether it is running on mobile at all.
- Any popup converting 8% or more: good by every source here; above Klaviyo’s “low bar” and in the range one of its senior strategists describes as achievable. Shift attention from the rate to what the subscribers go on to spend.
- A wheel or quiz converting 4 to 5%: weak for the format. Gamified popups average 8.67% (Sleeknote) to 13.23% (OptiMonk); at 4% the mechanic is not the problem, the offer or the placement is.
- Desktop-only popup: you are skipping the two-thirds of Shopify sessions that happen on mobile (Littledata’s median is 66%) and the device where both datasets measured the higher rate. Add a mobile version with a teaser before you test anything else.
The 96% the popup did not convert
Here is the part the vendor studies cannot tell you. A popup that converts 4.23% of views is dismissed by 95.77% of them, and what those visitors do in the ten seconds after closing it is where a popup earns or loses its keep on a Shopify store. A welcome offer that covers the add-to-cart button on a phone, a close button too small to hit on the first tap, a wheel that fires on a returning customer who already has the code: none of that shows up in an opt-in rate, and all of it shows up in rage clicks and dead clicks around the popup.
That is where session replay earns its place next to the popup tool. Filter recordings to mobile visitors on your top landing page, watch the first fifteen seconds of twenty sessions, and you will see how people actually meet the popup: whether they read it, where they tap to close it, and whether they are still on the page afterwards. A click heatmap of the same page shows you whether the close button is getting more taps than the offer. Then compare the store’s conversion rate against the 2026 benchmarks with the popup on and off for a week each; the opt-in rate is only half of what a popup costs or earns.
What to do with all these numbers
The honest takeaway from a popup stats post is not “hit 11%.” It is three things:
- Benchmark against the right number. A plain email popup against 3 to 5% (Klaviyo, Sleeknote, Wisepops), a discount popup against about 7.65%, a gamified one against 8.67% to 13.23%. Never against the pooled 11.09%.(source)(source)
- Turn it on for mobile, with a teaser. Both 2026 datasets have mobile converting higher; only 41% of Shopify stores show a mobile popup.(source)
- Measure revenue, not just opt-ins. Klaviyo’s discount data (90% more subscribers, 60% more revenue per subscriber) is the argument for an offer; Wisepops’ $128 per 1,000 impressions is the scale of what is at stake.(source)(source)
Most stores benefit more from one mobile version of their existing popup and one honest look at what visitors do after they close it than from chasing a vendor’s platform average built from stores that mostly sell nothing like what they sell. Want to sanity-check your conversion rate and cart abandonment against 2026 benchmarks while you are at it? We built a free Shopify Benchmark Checker for exactly that.
Trying to work out what visitors do after they close your popup? Propel Replays is the session replay tool we make for Shopify. Filter recordings by device and landing page, watch the first seconds of a visit, and see whether the offer is landing or just getting in the way. Free up to 750 pageviews per month, 30-day retention on every plan, unlimited click and area heatmaps, and 0ms impact on Core Web Vitals (Lighthouse-measured). Install in under 30 seconds.
Sources
- Sleeknote: Popup Statistics 2026, original data from 516M+ views (516,866,935 views, 21,875,675 leads; 4.23% average, up from 4.13%; centered 4.68%, slide-in 3.69%, sticky bar 2.85%; mobile 5.60% vs desktop 2.86%; spin-to-win 8.67% vs 3.70%; daily offers 29.59%; quizzes 8.65%; timer trigger 4.42% vs scroll 2.64%; one field 4.41%, two 2.90%, three 1.93%; 76% complete step two; images 4.05% vs 0.66%; countdown 5.17% vs 4.12%; teaser 4.54% vs 2.74%; November 9.3%, +52.5% subscribers, 67% mobile), published 13 August 2026
- Wisepops: Onsite Engagement Channel Benchmarks 2026 (2,547 sites, January to June 2026; popup engagement rate 4.5% on 22.6M impressions across 2,461 sites; 210,634 emails captured; $128 attributed revenue per 1,000 popup impressions vs $779 for the onsite feed; popups 76.6% of impressions and 83.0% of attributed revenue; method and metric definitions)
- Wisepops: The State of Visitor Engagement on Shopify Stores, 2026 edition (500 Shopify stores, $100k to $250k monthly revenue, 1 March to 10 June 2026; 69% run popups, 61% discount-for-email, 41% mobile popups, 48% multi-step, 38% more than one campaign, 39% phone capture, 8% returning-visitor campaign, 74% first-order discount with 10% off most common at 32%, Klaviyo on 68%; 2023 and 2018 comparisons; methodology), published 29 July 2026
- Klaviyo: 11 email pop-up best practices (Klaviyo’s general benchmark submit rate for sign-up forms of 3%; a senior digital strategist there has worked with brands at 8 to 20%), updated 6 November 2026
- Klaviyo Help Center: Understanding sign-up form analytics (submit rate defined as submitted form events divided by viewed form events, counting every visitor; peer benchmark statuses; bot removal from view counts)
- Klaviyo: Data about discounts on sign-up forms (90% higher subscription rates; 190% more likely to make a first purchase; almost 200% more revenue per view; 60% higher revenue per sign-up), updated July 2026
- OptiMonk: What are the most important popup statistics in 2026? (11.09% average; top 10% 42.35%; desktop 9.69%, mobile 11.07%; cart abandonment 17.12%; lucky wheel 13.23%; feedback 12.62%; seasonal 11.88%; newsletter 5.10%, ebook 7.49%, discount 7.65%; quiz 15.2%; countdown 14.41% vs 9.86%; images 11.09% vs 11.08%; fullscreen 14.40%), updated 22 October 2026
- Littledata: Mobile traffic share benchmark (median 66% across 438 Shopify stores, October 2026; middle 60% of stores between 40% and 81%)
- Average ecommerce conversion rate by industry, 2026 (companion post)
- Average cart abandonment rate, 2026 (companion post)