Honest comparison · Updated November 2026

The best PostHog alternative for Shopify,
ranked honestly.

PostHog is an excellent product-analytics platform for engineering teams, and session replay is one of the things it does. Most Shopify merchants who go looking for an alternative installed it for the replays and found themselves paying for, and configuring, a platform. Here are the six best PostHog alternatives for Shopify merchants, with prices read from each vendor this month, real trade-offs, and the cases where PostHog is still the right answer.

Jump to the ranked list See the side-by-side table
6 ALTERNATIVES · COMPARED ON SHOPIFY-FIT, PRICING, AND SETUP
TL;DR

The short answer.

PostHog is an open-source, MIT-licensed product-analytics platform: event tracking, funnels, feature flags, A/B experiments, SQL access and session replay in one tool, installed through a JavaScript SDK. Its replay product is free for the first 5,000 recordings a month and then metered, starting at $0.005 a recording, with one month of retention on the free plan and 90 days on paid. None of that is a flaw. It is a well-built platform for teams that have engineers and a product to iterate on.

If you run a Shopify store and you are looking for a PostHog alternative, the answer is almost always Propel Replays: the Shopify-native session replay app, installed from the App Store as a theme app embed with no SDK and no event schema, with replays that filter by every Shopify customer field, insight alerts that surface the day's biggest orders and abandoned carts, product-page alerts, and a tracking script with a measured 0ms impact on Core Web Vitals. Free up to 750 pageviews a month with unlimited heatmaps.

If you want free at any volume and are not only on Shopify, Microsoft Clarity is the closest thing to PostHog's free tier with none of the setup. MIDA is the other Shopify-native app. Contentsquare (where Hotjar's pricing page now sends you) is the suite for larger teams that want funnels and heatmaps at scale. Lucky Orange bundles live chat. Mouseflow has the deepest friction and form analytics.

One honest caveat up front: nothing on this page replaces PostHog's product analytics, feature flags, experiments or self-hosting. This page is for the replay and heatmap job. If you need the rest, keep PostHog, and consider running Propel beside it for the Shopify-shaped part.

Why people search for this

Why Shopify merchants are looking for a PostHog alternative in 2026.

Give PostHog its due first. It is open source under the MIT license and can be self-hosted, which almost nothing else in this category can say. It puts replays, product analytics, funnels, retention cohorts, feature flags, experiments and SQL access in one place. It has AI inside the replay product. It is honest about who it is for; PostHog's own marketing calls it dev tools for product engineers. Four things send Shopify merchants looking anyway:

  1. The setup assumes a developer. PostHog is installed as a JavaScript SDK, through a snippet or a tag manager, and gets useful when someone defines events, identifies users and configures autocapture. A Shopify merchant without an engineer spends the first week on instrumentation they never needed. The Shopify-native apps below install as a theme app embed and record within 30 seconds.
  2. The filters do not know what a Shopify customer is. PostHog has no out-of-the-box concept of a Shopify customer, order, cart, variant or market; whatever Shopify shape you want in your filters, you build by forwarding data through code. Propel and MIDA map Shopify customer and order fields into the filter UI by default.
  3. The bill stacks, and the recordings expire. Replay is metered per recording past 5,000 a month ($0.005 each to start), and product analytics, feature flags and experiments each meter separately. Recordings are kept for one month on the free plan and 90 days on paid unless you buy a retention add-on. A store that wants to go back and watch last quarter's launch cannot.
  4. They only ever wanted the replays. The most common story: a founder or agency installed PostHog because it was free and open source, used the session replay, and never touched the flags or experiments. At that point they are configuring and paying for a platform to get one feature a focused tool does better for a store.

Notice what is not on the list: PostHog is not shutting down, not sampling replays, and not mid-acquisition. If you have engineers and you use the platform, it is a very good tool. This page is for the merchant who does not and did not.

Ranked alternatives

The 6 best PostHog alternatives for Shopify, ranked.

Each entry covers what it is, who it fits, pricing, where it shines, and where it falls short. Listed in order of fit-for-Shopify. We built one of these, and we will be honest about the trade-offs anyway.

1

Propel Replays

Best for Shopify

The replay job PostHog was installed for, pre-shaped for Shopify: no SDK, no event schema, filters that already know your customers.

Propel Replays is a Shopify-native session replay, heatmap and survey app from Propel Commerce, a small independent studio that has been shipping Shopify apps since 2019. It started as the tool our founder wanted while running a Shopify store and trying to work out why paid traffic was not converting. It launched on the Shopify App Store in 2021 and is rated 4.9 stars across 700+ reviews at the time of writing.

What it does: records every visitor session, generates click and area heatmaps for any page (unlimited on every plan, including free), AI-summarizes each replay into two sentences when you open it, runs surveys on all pages, specific products, products by collection or time on page, ships conversion funnels, and lets you filter every replay by any Shopify customer field: order count, total spent, customer tag, cart value, UTM, device, country. Insight alerts surface the day's biggest orders, biggest abandoned carts and biggest abandoned checkouts relative to your store's baseline; product-page alerts flag drops in add-to-cart rate on product pages before they bleed conversion.

Where it wins vs PostHog: everything that made PostHog feel like work. Install is a theme app embed from the App Store, so there is no SDK, no identify call and no event taxonomy; recordings start within 30 seconds. The filters speak Shopify out of the box, where PostHog needs you to forward customer and order data through code. Insight alerts and product-page alerts do the triage PostHog leaves to you. Retention is 30 days on every plan including free, against one month free and 90 days paid on PostHog. The tracking script loads async after the rest of the page with a measured 0ms impact on Core Web Vitals; we do not have a published Lighthouse benchmark for PostHog's SDK, so we will not put a number on theirs. And support is a named human: Tom, our Support Team Lead, is called out by name in App Store reviews.

Where it falls short: it is a focused tool. No product analytics dashboards, no feature flags, no A/B testing framework, no SQL access, no API export (CSV from the dashboard only), and it is not open source or self-hostable. Heatmaps today are click and area; scroll and movement maps are on the roadmap. Shopify only. If any of the PostHog platform features are load-bearing for you, read the full head-to-head before deciding, or run both.

"Designed in a way that's tailored to how shop owners use this kind of data."

Strudel3D · Shopify App Store review

"This is much better because it's in Shopify."

Strudel3D · Shopify App Store review
Pricing
Free up to 750 pageviews/mo. Basic $9.90/mo for 20,000 pageviews (or $7.43/mo annual). 7-day free trial. Unlimited heatmaps on every plan.
Best for
Shopify stores and Shopify Plus brands that want the replay layer without the platform, and filters that already understand their customers.
Install free on Shopify See the full Replays product page
2

Microsoft Clarity

Free at any volume

The closest thing to PostHog's free tier with none of the setup. Free, no traffic limits, five heatmap types, any platform.

What it is: Microsoft's free behavioural analytics tool. Session recordings, heatmaps, dead-click and rage-click detection, per-replay AI summaries, a Google Analytics integration. No paid tier; Microsoft's own FAQ says it is free with no traffic, site or member limits.

Where it wins vs PostHog: if "free and open to any site" is what drew you to PostHog, Clarity gives you the free part without the meter: no 5,000-recording ceiling, no per-recording rate past it, and a paste-the-script install rather than an SDK and an event schema. Clarity's documentation lists click maps (all, dead, rage, error, first and last clicks), scroll maps, area maps, conversion maps and attention maps, with no minimum traffic to generate one (the real tradeoffs of "free forever").

Where it falls short for Shopify: like PostHog, it does not know what a Shopify customer is. Filters do not map to Shopify customer fields, replays do not link back to orders, there is no Shopify App Store listing, and the data lives on Microsoft's servers under terms that allow aggregated, anonymized use of it. There is also none of PostHog's analytics depth: no funnels you define, no flags, no experiments, no SQL. Good free backstop; weaker primary tool for a Shopify merchant.

Pricing
Free, unlimited. No paid tier. 30-day recording retention.
Best for
Non-Shopify or multi-platform sites, zero budgets, and a free backstop beside a Shopify-native tool.
3

MIDA

Other Shopify-native app

The other session replay app built on Shopify primitives, with scroll maps and revenue-overlaid heatmaps on its higher plans.

What it is: a Shopify-only session replay and heatmap app, on the App Store since July 2022 with a Built for Shopify badge, rated 4.9 stars across 610 reviews when we last checked. Click and scroll maps on every plan, revenue click and conversion heatmaps on Growth and above, order-linked recordings, per-replay AI summaries, bot filtering and an AI Assistant add-on.

Where it wins vs PostHog: the same thing Propel wins on, the Shopify shape. It installs from the App Store as a theme app embed, its replays link to orders, and its filters understand Shopify customers without any instrumentation. If scroll depth and revenue-per-click on the page are your weekly questions, MIDA has those maps today (Propel vs MIDA, MIDA alternatives).

Where it falls short: it meters by sessions, and the entry tier is small: Basic is $9.90/mo for 5,000 sessions against Propel's 20,000 pageviews at the same price. The revenue and conversion heatmaps it leads with start on the $24.90/mo Growth plan. Like Propel it is Shopify only, so a brand with a non-Shopify property needs one of the multi-platform tools here. And like every tool on this page, nothing about it is open source or self-hostable.

Pricing (App Store)
Free up to 250 sessions/mo. Basic $9.90/mo (5,000 sessions), Growth $24.90/mo (15,000), Enterprise $44.90/mo (40,000). 7-day trial.
Best for
Shopify stores whose weekly question is scroll depth or revenue per click on a page.
4

Contentsquare (Hotjar)

The suite option

The closest thing here to a platform: replays, heatmaps, funnels, journeys and surveys, with a huge free tier on analytics volume and sampled replays below Pro.

What it is: a full digital-experience analytics suite: session replay, click, scroll and move maps, zone-based heatmaps that attach engagement and revenue metrics to each page element, journey analysis, funnels and surveys. hotjar.com/pricing redirects here, so this is the product a Hotjar signup actually gets.

Where it wins vs PostHog: if what you liked about PostHog was having funnels and journeys next to the replays, Contentsquare is the no-code version of that for marketing teams. The free plan covers up to 200,000 sessions a month with heatmaps, funnels and replays included, and the analytics history runs to 13 months on Growth. Enterprise procurement is there if you need it.

Where it falls short: the self-serve plans sample session replays. Contentsquare's own plan table reads 5% of sessions captured on Free and 15% on Growth, with full capture only on the quoted Pro and Enterprise plans, so the specific session behind an abandoned cart usually was not recorded; PostHog records every session you pay for. Growth starts at $49/mo on monthly billing for 7,000 sessions. The filter model is user IDs and custom variables, not Shopify customers and orders, and the Shopify App Store listing (December 2025) had no reviews when we last checked (Contentsquare pricing 2026, Contentsquare alternatives).

Pricing
Free up to 200,000 sessions/mo (1-month data access, 5% of replays). Growth from $49/mo monthly, $39/mo annual, for 7,000 sessions.
Best for
Larger marketing teams that want aggregate funnels and heatmaps without code, and enterprise buyers comparing suites.
5

Lucky Orange

Widest feature bundle

The multi-platform veteran with a Built for Shopify badge, live chat in the bundle, and a free App Store plan.

What it is: Lucky Orange has been around since 2010. Session recordings, click, scroll and movement heatmaps, conversion funnels, surveys, announcements, form analytics and live chat in one subscription. On the Shopify App Store it is rated 4.6 stars across 902 reviews and carries the Built for Shopify badge.

Where it wins vs PostHog: it installs from the App Store with no SDK, it bundles things PostHog does not (live chat and on-site announcements next to the recording), and it runs on anything that hosts a script, so a Shopify store plus a non-Shopify property is one tool. The App Store ladder starts with a free plan of 100 sessions a month and a $19/mo Launch plan for 500 sessions (full Lucky Orange pricing breakdown).

Where it falls short: the session allowances are small for the money (3,500 sessions on the $39/mo Build plan, against PostHog's 5,000 recordings free), the script bundles every feature into one payload, the filters are built for generic web properties rather than Shopify customer fields, and there are two different price ladders depending on whether you read luckyorange.com or the App Store listing. The UI also shows its 15 years.

Pricing (App Store)
Free up to 100 sessions/mo. Launch $19/mo (500 sessions), Build $39/mo (3,500), Grow $89/mo (10,000). 20% off yearly.
Best for
Stores wanting live chat and announcements bundled with replays, or running more than one platform.
6

Mouseflow

Deepest friction analytics

Seven heatmap types and the deepest friction and form analytics in the category. Multi-platform, no Shopify lane.

What it is: a Danish behaviour-analytics tool whose heatmap set is the widest in the category: click, scroll, movement, attention, friction, interactive and geo, with a split view to compare any two. Friction detection (rage clicks, dead clicks, error clicks, form drop-off) is the loudest and best feature. There is a free plan at 500 sessions a month.

Where it wins vs PostHog: it is a behaviour tool first, so the friction scoring and per-field form analytics go deeper than a replay feature inside an analytics platform, and it installs with a script rather than an SDK and an event schema. Essential is $25/mo on annual billing for 5,000 sessions, Advanced $109/mo, Premium $319/mo (full Mouseflow pricing breakdown).

Where it falls short: no Shopify App Store listing, no Shopify-specific filters, and most of the seven heatmap types answer questions a storefront rarely asks. A Shopify store has two forms that matter, checkout and newsletter capture, and checkout is off-limits to a storefront script anyway. The free plan is a tenth of PostHog's.

Pricing
Free up to 500 sessions/mo. Essential from $25/mo on annual billing for 5,000 sessions.
Best for
Form-heavy sites and teams whose CRO work is friction-event triage.
At a glance

PostHog alternatives, side-by-side.

The same six tools plus PostHog itself, scored on the things that matter for Shopify merchants, including how each one gets onto your store and whether it is open source.

Tool Shopify-native? Install Free tier? Starts at Open source? App Store rating
Propel Replays Yes App Store, theme app embed 750 pageviews/mo, unlimited heatmaps $9.90/mo (20,000 pageviews) No 4.9★ (700+ reviews)
PostHog No JavaScript SDK, events you define 5,000 recordings/mo, 1-month retention $0.005/recording past 5,000 (about $67.50 at 20,000) Yes (MIT), self-hostable No listing
Microsoft Clarity No Paste a script Unlimited (free only) Free No No listing
MIDA Yes App Store, theme app embed 250 sessions/mo $9.90/mo (5,000 sessions) No 4.9★ (610 reviews)
Contentsquare (Hotjar) No (App Store listing, Dec 2025) Script or App Store listing 200,000 sessions/mo, 5% of replays $49/mo monthly (7,000 sessions) No No reviews yet
Lucky Orange No (App Store install) App Store 100 sessions/mo $19/mo (500 sessions) No 4.6★ (902 reviews)
Mouseflow No Paste a script 500 sessions/mo $25/mo annual (5,000 sessions) No No listing

PostHog figures are from its published pricing tiers on 2 November 2026 (session replay product only; product analytics, feature flags and experiments meter separately). The $67.50 figure is 10,000 recordings at $0.005 plus 5,000 at $0.0035 after the 5,000 free. Other prices reflect the lowest non-free paid plan on each vendor's Shopify App Store listing or pricing page when we last checked them (26 October 2026); Lucky Orange's own site lists a different ladder. App Store ratings are Shopify App Store.

Migration guide

Switching from PostHog to Propel.

Start by being honest about which parts of PostHog you used in the last 90 days. If the answer includes feature flags, experiments, SQL queries or self-hosting, keep PostHog; nothing on this page replaces those, and the sensible move is to add Propel beside it for the Shopify-shaped replay work. If the answer is "I watched the session replays and never set up an event", the switch is cheap and the alerts will do the watching for you.

The standard "what about my data?" worry: you cannot migrate it, and this is industry-wide rather than a PostHog problem. Session replays are stored as compressed DOM events in a vendor-specific format, so they do not translate between tools. PostHog keeps recordings for one month on the free plan and 90 days on paid, so most of what you have expires on its own schedule anyway. Fresh data accumulates fast. A store doing a few hundred sessions a day has readable click heatmaps within 24 to 48 hours of installing Propel and a useful replay library inside a week.

Concrete remapping for Shopify merchants moving from PostHog to Propel: session replays → covered, every session, plus an AI summary on each and insight alerts that surface the day's biggest orders, biggest abandoned carts and biggest abandoned checkouts. Replay filters → every Shopify customer field, out of the box, with no identify calls or custom properties to define. Funnels → Propel ships conversion funnels, and Shopify Analytics covers the storefront funnel natively. Heatmaps → click and area heatmaps, unlimited on every plan; scroll and movement maps are on the roadmap. Surveys → covered on every plan, triggered on all pages, specific products, products by collection or time on page, with responses linked to the replay behind them. Feature flags, experiments, SQL access, self-hosting, API export → not covered. Keep PostHog for those or pick a dedicated tool.

The mechanics: install Propel from the Shopify App Store, toggle the theme app embed on, and recordings start within 30 seconds; there is no snippet to paste and no theme.liquid to edit. Run both for a week or two on the same traffic and compare the dashboards on real sessions, not demo data. When you are ready, remove the PostHog snippet from wherever it was added (your theme or your tag manager) and let the project wind down. Export anything you specifically want to keep first.

— FAQ

PostHog alternative FAQ

Why would a Shopify merchant look for a PostHog alternative?
Usually because PostHog turned out to be the wrong shape rather than a bad tool. PostHog is a product-analytics platform built for engineering teams: you install a JavaScript SDK, define events, and get session replay alongside feature flags, experiments and SQL access. A Shopify merchant who installed it for the replays finds the setup assumes a developer, the filters do not know what a Shopify customer or order is, and the bill stacks across products. The other common reason is retention: recordings on PostHog's free plan are kept for one month and on the pay-as-you-go plan for 90 days, which is fine for a product team shipping weekly and short for a store looking back at last quarter's launch.
What's the best PostHog alternative for Shopify?
Propel Replays. It does the replay job PostHog was installed for, pre-shaped for Shopify: installs from the App Store as a theme app embed with no SDK and no event schema, filters every replay by any Shopify customer field (order count, total spent, customer tag, cart value, UTM, device, country), surfaces the day's biggest orders and abandoned carts through insight alerts, flags add-to-cart drops on product pages, and has a measured 0ms impact on Core Web Vitals. Free up to 750 pageviews a month with unlimited heatmaps; Basic is $9.90/mo for 20,000 pageviews. The full head-to-head is at Propel vs PostHog.
Is PostHog free?
Partly. PostHog's session replay product is free for the first 5,000 recordings a month, with one month of recording retention on the free plan. Past that it is metered: $0.005 per recording up to 15,000 a month, $0.0035 up to 50,000, $0.002 up to 150,000, $0.0017 up to 500,000 and $0.0015 beyond, per PostHog's published tiers in November 2026, with 90-day retention on the paid plan. So 20,000 recordings a month costs about $67.50 for replay alone, and 50,000 about $172.50. Product analytics, feature flags and experiments each meter separately on top. PostHog also publishes an MIT-licensed open-source version you can self-host, where the software is free and the infrastructure is yours.
How does PostHog compare to Propel on price for a Shopify store?
At the free tier PostHog is more generous on raw volume: 5,000 recordings a month against Propel's 750 pageviews. Past it the picture flips for a typical store. Propel's Basic plan is $9.90/mo for 20,000 pageviews (about 7,700 sessions at Littledata's Shopify median of 2.6 pages per session), and Enterprise is $59.90/mo for 100,000 pageviews. PostHog's replay meter alone reaches $67.50/mo at 20,000 recordings and $172.50 at 50,000. If you also use PostHog for analytics, flags or experiments the total is higher still, and if you only wanted the replays you are paying for a platform you do not use. Check both live pricing pages before buying; PostHog adjusts its tiers periodically.
Can I keep PostHog and add Propel?
Yes, and some Shopify Plus brands do exactly that. PostHog stays as the engineering data layer (product analytics, feature flags, experiments) and Propel handles the Shopify-shaped replay, heatmap and survey workflow for the merchandising and CRO side. The two scripts are independent and do not interfere. The combination makes sense when an engineering team has standardised on PostHog and the people watching replays are not engineers.
Do any of these alternatives self-host or export like PostHog?
No, and we would rather say so than pretend. PostHog's MIT-licensed open-source edition and its full data export (API, CSV, direct database access when self-hosted) are genuinely differentiated. Every tool on this page is a managed cloud service. Propel offers one-click CSV export of session data from the dashboard and no replay API. If self-hosting or warehouse-grade portability is a hard requirement, PostHog is the right tool and this page will not change that.
Will I lose my PostHog recordings if I switch?
You cannot migrate them, and this is true across the whole category. Session replays are stored as compressed DOM events in a vendor-specific format, so they do not translate between tools. PostHog's retention is one month on the free plan and 90 days on paid, so most of what you have will expire on its own schedule anyway. Fresh data accumulates fast: a store doing a few hundred sessions a day has readable click heatmaps within 24 to 48 hours of installing a new tool and a useful replay library inside a week.
How long does it take to switch from PostHog to Propel?
Under an hour of active work, and most of that is on the PostHog side. Propel installs from the Shopify App Store as a theme app embed: toggle it on and recordings start within 30 seconds, with no snippet to paste and no theme.liquid to edit. PostHog was installed as a JavaScript SDK, either as a snippet in your theme or through a tag manager, so removing it means finding where it was added and taking it out. Run both for a week or two on the same traffic first, compare the dashboards on real sessions, then remove the PostHog snippet and let the project expire.

The replay layer, without the platform.

Install Propel Replays in under 30 seconds. Unlimited heatmaps and every session recorded on every plan. Free up to 750 pageviews/mo. 7-day free trial on every paid plan.

Install free on Shopify
— Related

Keep reading

Pillar
Propel Replays for Shopify
The full picture of why shoppers don't buy.
Read more →
Head-to-head
Propel vs PostHog
The full feature-by-feature comparison, including when PostHog is the right tool.
Read more →
Listicle
Best Shopify session replay apps in 2026
Seven replay tools ranked for Shopify stores, with honest picks for each situation.
Read more →